What Happened To Allan Bakke

Teaching

Didactics; The Bakke Case 10 Years Subsequently: Mixed Results

July thirteen, 1988

Credit... The New York Times Archives

See the article in its original context from
July 13, 1988

Section B , Page

half-dozenBuy Reprints

TimesMachine is an exclusive do good for abode commitment and digital subscribers.

About the Annal

This is a digitized version of an article from The Times's print archive, before the start of online publication in 1996. To preserve these articles every bit they originally appeared, The Times does not change, edit or update them.

Occasionally the digitization procedure introduces transcription errors or other problems; we are continuing to piece of work to improve these archived versions.

Some supporters of affirmative activeness called the Supreme Court ruling a stunning setback. Yet even opponents were troubled that it had legitimized the use of racial considerations in decisions on schoolhouse admissions.

Ten years have passed since the Supreme Court ordered the medical school of the University of California at Davis to admit Allan Bakke, a white student who said he was a victim of reverse discrimination.

The Court decided that Mr. Bakke deserved to exist admitted, but at the same fourth dimension it upheld the apply of race as a factor in admissions policy.

Although judgments well-nigh the affect of the example are as split as the Court's v-to-4 decision, educational experts seem to agree that, while the bleakest prophecies of civil rights supporters did not come true, the Bakke decision left aggressiveness in albeit members of minority groups a thing of a school's predilections rather than a affair of law. Slight Gains at Police force Schools

Medical and law schoolhouse associations say the numbers of black, Hispanic and other minority students have held steady and in some cases, increased slightly since the Bakke decision.

In 1978, 3,587 blacks were enrolled in American medical schools, representing half dozen percent of their enrollment. This year the figure is 3,968, also six percentage. In 1978, five,304 blacks were enrolled in the nation's law schools, or iv.7 percent of the enrollment. The effigy rose to 6,028 this year, or five.1 percent.

''The Supreme Court decision really encouraged affirmative action goals by allowing the use of race and other determinants in academic achievement as acceptable admissions criteria,'' Dr. Robert G. Petersdorf, president of the Association of American Medical Colleges, said in a statement assessing the affect of the Bakke decision.

The proportion of minority students at medical and law schools, however, notwithstanding remains well below their representation in the general population. Educators say the problem is 1 that cannot exist changed quickly past conventional affirmative action methods. Fewer Minority Undergraduates

At the root of the problem is the fact that the number of minority students who are undergraduates has declined. In 1978 there were ane,054,000 blacks enrolled at 3,200 colleges surveyed by the Department of Educational activity. The effigy peaked at 1,107,000 in 1980, and so dropped for several years before rising slightly in 1986 to 1,081,000.

One explaination for the drop, says Dr. Reginald Wilson, director of the Part of Minority Concerns of the American Council on Education, is that the Bakke ruling had a ''chilling effect on institutions fearing they might be charged with reverse bigotry.'' Medical, law and engineering science schools were an exception, he said, because they accept recognized how severely underrepresented minorities were in their professions.

Indeed, Mr. Wilson and others suggested that the affect of the Bakke case varied with the convictions of individual schools. The ruling's ambiguity allowed cautious schools to interpret the case conservatively, while those intent on pursuing minority students took a broader reading.

Critics of affirmative activeness say the Bakke determination heightened the significance of race in deciding admissions, diminishing the weight of individual merit and leading to a turn down in academic standards. Bakke'due south Arguments Reviewed

In his lawsuit, Mr. Bakke argued that he had twice been rejected by the Davis schoolhouse despite being better qualified than those admitted to the 16 seats specifically prepare aside for minority students.

In one of his applications, Mr. Bakke's 3.51 grade indicate average and Medical Higher Access Exam percentiles of 96 in verbal, 94 in mathematics, 97 in science and 72 in general knowledge far surpassed those of minority students admitted with an average grade bespeak of 2.88 and an average admission test score of 46 in verbal, 24 in math, 35 in science and 33 in general noesis.

The Supreme Court'due south ruling on June 28, 1978, produced six written opinions. The controlling one, by Acquaintance Justice Lewis F. Powell Jr., ordered Davis to admit Mr. Bakke. Justice Powell asserted that, without a finding of by discrimination, the set-aside program, violated Mr. Bakke'south rights under the the 14th Admendment'due south guarantee of equal protection of the laws. But, in a key compromise, Justice Powell said race could be taken into business relationship by admissions officers to promote campus diversity.

Mr. Bakke, who is now 48 years old, was graduated from Davis in 1982. He returned to his native Minnesota, and is now an anesthesiologist on the staff of Olmstead Community Hospital in Rochester, Minn. He declines to exist interviewed about the example. Davis's Recruiting Intensified

In looking at the bear on of the ruling, the experience of the Davis medical school itself is telling. Dr. Hibbard E. Williams, dean of the school, said there was a drop in minority students in the years immediately subsequently the ruling because the instance fostered the impression that the school would non be receptive to such students.

Merely Davis, intent on increasing the number of physicians in black, Chicano and Indian areas, turned that impression around by intensifying recruiting efforts, he said.

Among its programs, Davis invites minority college sophomores and juniors for a summertime session aimed at whetting interests in medical careers. Dr. Williams said that Davis, in selecting medical school applicants goes beyond grades and looks at such criteria as groundwork, motivation and ability to deal with people.

From 1983 to 1987 Davis admitted an boilerplate of 15 percentage of students classified as members of minority groups, college than the schoolhouse's xiii percent rate in the 5 years before the Bakke conclusion. Affirmative Action Continues

''Bakke was significant considering it didn't put the brakes on affirmative action,'' said Rennard Strickland, dean of the Southern Illinois University Law School and former chairman of the minority enrollment job force of the Law School Admission Quango. ''Most police schools connected doing after Bakke what they had done before Bakke.''

Mr. Strickland said that when he took over at Southern Illinois in 1985 there was one black among the 102 outset-year students. That number rose to 13 concluding fall through vigorous recruiting efforts and generous financial assistance, he said.

Samuel Rabinove, legal managing director for the American Jewish Committee, said that even though Justice Powell's opinion disapproved of ''preferential classifications,'' schools continue to give preferences to minority students in admissions. The committee joined with Italian, Polish, Greek and other largely white indigenous associations in filing a cursory supporting Bakke's complaint.

''Individual merit has never been strictly practical,'' he said.''In universities generally, there accept always been preferences for children of alumni, for skilled athletes and musicians.'' In the brief, the committee argued that preferences should exist given to students who accept overcome economic handicaps, just such decisions should be non be made strictly on the basis of race.